Legendary Rochester Bakery Casa Saratoga Reopens in Gates

Frank Martusciello's beloved Casa Saratoga bakery has reopened in Gates, NY. Discover the legendary Italian bread, pizzas, and pastries at the new location.

By GetAwayRochester ยท Published

For generations, the Martusciello name has been synonymous with exceptional Italian bread in Rochester, NY. After closing its doors in 2022, the legendary Casa Saratoga bakery has officially reopened as of July 13, 2026, much to the delight of carb-lovers across the region. Now located at 475 Spencerport Road in Gates, the bakery's return is being celebrated by loyal customers who have missed their favorite crusty loaves and sweet treats.

A Rochester Baking Legacy Continues

The story of this beloved Rochester institution began in the late 1950s when Gaetano and Maria Martusciello started baking and selling bread from their home on Saratoga Avenue. Over the decades, their son, Frank Martusciello, took the helm, growing the business and eventually moving it to Lyell Avenue in 1996 under the name Casa Saratoga.

Though Frank closed the bakery a few years ago due to rising ingredient costs and staffing challenges, the 71-year-old baker could not stay away for long. Calling this reopening his "second encore," Frank has scaled down the operation to focus on what he does best. If you are exploring the local culinary landscape, this is a must-visit spot that perfectly complements our guide to Rochester's best restaurants.

What to Expect at the New Casa Saratoga

The new retail-only shop is situated in a former Pizza Hut building, right next door to another local favorite, Savastano's Bakery and Pizzeria. Despite the proximity to a competitor, Casa Saratoga offers a distinct menu that focuses on the classics.

Visitors can expect to find an array of Italian rolls, hard crust breads, cookies, brownies, and cannoli. For savory options, Frank is baking up 9-inch pizzas and calzones made in traditional pie plates. The bakery is open Monday through Saturday from 9:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., and is closed on Sundays. If you are planning a food tour of the area, consider pairing your visit with a stop on the Rochester craft beer trail or checking out some Rochester hidden gems and underrated spots.

The Heart of Rochester's Food Scene

The enthusiastic response to Casa Saratoga's return highlights the strong community ties and rich food culture in the Rochester area. On opening morning, a steady stream of loyal customers lined up for hard crust loaves, with some regulars buying seven at a time to deliver to friends and family across town. That kind of devotion says everything about how deeply this bakery is woven into the fabric of the community. Local businesses like this are what make the region's neighborhoods so special, from Gates and Greece on the west side to the walkable streets featured in our Park Avenue Rochester neighborhood guide. If you are considering putting down roots in the area, you can learn more by exploring our complete guide to buying a home in Rochester, NY or browsing current real estate listings.

Whether you are a long-time fan or a newcomer eager to taste a piece of local history, Casa Saratoga is ready to welcome you back. Grab a loaf of bread and a few cannoli, then spend the rest of your Saturday browsing fresh produce and local vendors with help from our Rochester Public Market complete visitors guide. Visitors making a weekend trip to the Flower City can find comfortable hotels and vacation rentals across Rochester just a short drive from Gates, and can fill their itinerary using our roundup of the top things to do in Rochester, NY. However you plan it, a warm loaf from Casa Saratoga is the perfect way to taste a true Rochester tradition.

More to Explore in Rochester